B1G Divisions to End Time Travel?

It's been no secret that the Big Ten is in favor of a geographical East-West split.  It seems likely that the Western division would include Nebraska, Wisconsin, Iowa, Northwestern, Illinois, and Minnesota.  Those six schools all share a time zone.  It's the seventh team that is the question mark. 

 

The four schools that are furthest west are Purdue, Indiana, Michigan State, and Michigan.  Sadly, sending one of these teams west will break up a rivalry.  Aside from preserving a single cross-rivalry, there doesn't appear to be any other matchup that truly matters.  Manufacturing a half-dozen new rivalries doesn't seem all that appealing or particularly fair.  

There seem to be a couple ways to handle that.  First, is just to end one of those rivalries as an annual event.  Ending Michigan-Michigan State would seem like a crime.  As for Indiana-Purdue?  Eh, who really cares.  Those are primarily basketball schools.  Another way to handle it would be to preserve a single cross-rivalry.  While other schools rotate, the one rivalry that matters would be preserved (this would have been a good option for Nebraska-Oklahoma in the Big 12, by the way).

The least disruptive split would seem to be sending Purdue (or Indiana) to the West.  One curious fact about the state of Indiana is that there are still a handful of counties that observe Central time.  Neither Big Ten school sits in one of those counties, but presumably they'd have some fans that do.  Purdue is slightly closer to those counties but Indiana may have more fans statewide.  

Those most concerned with competitive balance may think that adding Michigan State to a group that includes Ohio State, Michigan, Penn State, and Rutgers would create a bit of an East-West imbalance.  Also, Michigan State apparently likes playing in the Chicago market against Northwestern.  You could also argue that the Spartans have a nice rivalry emerging with Wisconsin.  All of those arguments are valid.  But ending the annual Spartan-Wolverine game seems like a deal-breaker.  

The Athletic Directors could still throw us a curve.  Some would argue that Nebraska and Penn State have both some history and perhaps the genesis of a good rivalry across divisions.  It's hard to come up with other cross-division games that are all that meaningful.  You could pair Ohio State with Wisconsin.  And perhaps the Indiana schools with those in Illinois.  But putting Iowa or Minnesota with Rutgers or Maryland just seems random and pointless. 

Shipping Purdue west and ending the designated cross-division rivalries would probably be the best thing overall.  Hopefully, the AD's see it the same way.
 

Share the Love

Comments 4 comments so far

Purdue-Indiana is very important for that state. It’s likely that one of those three schools (Michigan State, Indiana, Purdue) will end up west. Can’t move Michigan because then you would have to protect two games (Michigan State and Ohio State). Easiest route would be to just protect the important game for whichever team moves west. My bet is that MSU moves west and has their game with Michigan protected.

Purdue-Indiana is very important for that state? 20,000 empty seats at Purdue this year and 10,000 empty seats at Indiana last year show that it isn’t THAT important.

However, my guess and hope is that Aaron is correct on MSU being in the west after the dust settles.

Go B1G Red!

Bob

It would be better competition wise if you brought MSU in with the west.  Otherwise the east would be loaded with MSU/UM/PSU/OSU all battling it out for the division, while Neb and Wis get a fairly easy road.

Well, I think with the addition of Rutgers and Maryland we should probably do this:

B1G West:                B1G East:
Iowa                       Illinois
Indiana                     Maryland
Minnesotta                 Michigan
Nebraska                   Michigan St.
Northwestern             Ohio St
Purdue                     Penn St
Wisconsin                 Rutgers

Mkehret, I am going to have to disagree with you.  Nebraska is 7 - 0 against the Spartans.  Where this is both baffling and head scratcher, I think if given a choice MSU would rather play against their old adversaries with two new teams in their division rather than have to face Nebraska, Wisconsin, Michigan, and Iowa every year.

The saving grace about Purdue is, to this date, Purdue is the only B1G team Nebraska has never defeated!

Commenting is not available in this section entry.
More Recent Stories...